Podcast episode graphic titled Kids Dont Even Like Scrolling with Bill Brady, Episode 7, featuring a portrait of Troomi Founder Bill Brady speaking into a microphone.

Kids Don’t Even Like Scrolling. Why Can’t They Stop?

Host: Troomi CEO Bill Brady Guest: 

In this episode, host Bill Brady shares some staggering new statistics about children and screen time from Common Sense Media. The research found that kids often don’t even like the time they’re spending on screens, even though they can’t seem to stop. Bill also shares some practical advice for helping your kids get off their devices and spend more time doing things they actually enjoy.

Welcome to Protecting Childhood, a podcast about raising kids in a digital world. We help parents navigate technology with confidence, set healthy boundaries, and raise kids who thrive beyond the screen.

I’m Bill Brady, founder of Troomi. In today’s episode I’ll share some new research from Common Sense Media, including some numbers that are unbelievable but probably not surprising. We’ll talk about how kids really feel about the time they’re spending on screens and how we as parents can help them do things that are happier and more fulfilling with their time.

Since I got into the world of kid-safe tech back in 2018, I’ve frequently talked about statistics from common sense media that shed light on just how kids are doing and how they’re using technology and how they’re using media.

This week, common sense media released its first broad census of kids’ media and technology use in five years, and its findings deserve a slow, careful read from every parent. Surveying 1211 kids ages 9 to 17, the researchers found that the typical teen now spends more than eight hours a day on screens for entertainment alone and the typical tween about five. More than four in 10 teens spend 10 hours or more. The census also charts how quickly phones are arriving with kids. Personal smartphone ownership climbs from 24% at age 9 to 47% at age 10 and 57% at age 11, reaching a staggering 94% by age 17. 

You know, those stats really rang true to me because of a couple of recent experiences.

In May, I found myself in Los Angeles for a phenomenal event that we were helping to host and sponsor for teenage athletes, specifically teenage girl athletes. And during the course of that day, I got to talk directly to about 300 girls. As girls came through to visit, I asked every group, “So who has phones and who doesn’t have phones?” And in the whole course of that day, I met just three girls that didn’t have a smartphone. You know, that was about a 1% result from the sample size of girls I talked to. was blown away by that. The next month, I was in New York City and likewise talked to a large group of kids. And in that group, not a single one of those kids who ranged between 12 and 16 years old, not a single one didn’t have a smartphone. So I wasn’t surprised by these new statistics.

In this week’s report, Michael Robb, Common Sense Media’s head of research, described media and technology as almost like air in our kids’ lives. He’s right, and that’s precisely why we need to be asking what they’re breathing. Even more important than the time that they spend on devices is what they’re doing with that time. There are a couple of distinctions that can be made. You know, is the time going into creative processes or is it all just consuming content, whether that’s, you know, YouTube shorts or just doom scrolling social media versus what kids might be doing on devices to create things and build things and do something that’s productive.

You know, in the time that our kids are on devices, are those devices acting as a tool or are they acting as a tyrant? Have they become the default use for all of our kids’ free time? And those are things that we need to pay attention to. Really think of it. If you’re a parent looking at your kid’s device use, ask yourself the question, is my child’s use of a device adding to life or detracting from what life should be? And I know as a parent, that’s my greatest concern.

But the statistic that has stayed with me is it’s like I said, not just about the hours. According to the census, 86 percent of teens use social media, but only 47 percent of those users say they enjoy it a lot. Among teens who use A.I. in their free time, only 11 percent say they enjoy it a lot. And nearly half of teens believe they spend too much time on entertainment on screens. Think of that again. Our kids are giving the better part of their waking hours to experiences that most of them do not particularly love. And many of them already know it. As a pioneer of the kids safe technology movement, I’ve long believed that children are more perceptive about their own digital lives than we give them credit for. This report suggests they’re telling us something if we’re willing to listen.

Why would anyone spend hours on something they don’t enjoy? You might ask yourself that as a parent. You hear this statistic and say, if they don’t enjoy it, why do they do it? Well, behavioral science answered that question decades ago. In his experiments with pigeons, the famous psychologist B.F. Skinner found that rewards delivered on an unpredictable schedule kept birds from pecking more consistently than rewards that come every time. The slot machine is built on that same principle, and so is the endless feed in our social media platforms. The next video might be the funny one. The next notification might be the one that matters. Systems like these do not need to delight us. They only need to keep us reaching. The writer Annie Dillard once observed, “How we spend our days is, of course, how we spend our lives.” For a teenager, eight hours a day adds up to a childhood. Years ago, I read a phenomenal book from Henry David Thoreau called Walden.

And in that book, if you’re familiar with it, Thoreau did an experiment of his own. And he went and secluded himself in the forest for a year, living in a little cabin at Walden Pond. And in that, he did a lot of writing and reflecting about life and what life means. And a phenomenal book. It’s not long. It’s a great read. Something that struck me and stuck with me is a quote from that book: “The cost of a thing is the amount of what I will call life, which is required to be exchanged for it, immediately or in the long run.” Every hour a child gives to a feed is an hour not given to sleep, a book, a friend, or the outdoors.

That idea really comes to life for me as I reflect on a recent experience I had while speaking to a large auditorium of kids. I asked them all to close their eyes and remember three favorite memories and then open their eyes and write those memories down. And then I asked for volunteers to share. Unsurprisingly, the answers I heard centered on time with people, not devices. And many kids talked about being outside, being active, or exploring new places, not sitting in the basement behind the cold glow of a television, a phone, or a computer screen. 

In our family, we’ve tried really hard to have an outdoor lifestyle. We’re fortunate to live near the mouth of a canyon in some beautiful mountains. And I spend all of my free time with my kids there, with my boys in particular. We love camping and hiking and fishing and just being out in nature, even if just for a campfire for an evening. And with my wife, frequently our date night consists of going on a hike, and those are things that we love to do. 

A tradition that I’ve started with my own kids is to do what we call a spring adventure and a fall adventure. And they’re generally pretty hard. We try to do things that are going to take some time and have us off the grid doing hard things. And I remember a couple years ago, on the first of these bigger adventures, I took my son William when he was 12 years old on a 16-mile hike. In the first half of that, we were going to ascend about 2,000 feet in altitude gain. And I was carrying a pack that was a little over 40 pounds. He was carrying a pack that was about 20 pounds. And it had started great. And then we got to the snow.

We didn’t realize that the trail that we were taking was still covered in snow, even though it was the end of May. And for about 75% of that ascent, we were in snow that was post-holing up to our knees if we went through. It was exhausting, absolutely brutal. And when we got to the first night and set up our beds, we hiked into this place that we had predetermined where we would camp. And we were both just beside ourselves with exhaustion. But we got set up and we got a fire going, collected the wood we needed to collect. And as we sat there eating our freeze-dried meals, I said to William, “Buddy, this has been hard. What do you want to do? We can keep going, not knowing what is in store for us tomorrow, if it’s going to be more snow or if we’ll be into easier terrain. Or we could turn back and go back the way we came, because at least we know what we’re dealing with that way.”

And my son at 12 years old said, “Dad, of course we’re going to keep going. Of course we are. We don’t have any choice but to finish what we started.” And I said to him, “Well, tell me about your experience so far. What have you learned?” And he got quiet for a second. And he said, “I’ve already learned that I can do hard things.”

And the next day, thank goodness, wasn’t quite as bad. We went over the ascent on that trail. We went over the peak, and the rest of it was downhill. Not an easy downhill, but at least it didn’t have snow on it. And now two, three years have gone by, and when I ask William the same question I ask that group of kids, “Hey, what are the memories that stand out in your childhood so far? It’s experiences like that that are at the top of the list.” And he will never, he will never forget those brutal hikes with Dad, that one in particular in the snow, where he’s learned about who he is, and he’s learned what he’s capable of, and he’s had a time with his dad that he’ll never forget. So I think all of us as parents innately understand that the best experiences that we can have with our kids are not on devices, and they are doing memorable things, and they are frequently outside.

So why do so many of us feel powerless to change the pattern? Candidly, I think it’s because the problem feels too big. When screens are everywhere and every classmate seems to have a phone, it’s tempting to conclude that the battle’s already lost. In the research from Common Sense Media that I mentioned, their head of research, he actually warned against that instinct. He said, “It’s easy to be fatalistic and just say, well, kids are going to find a way if they want to find a way.” But he also offered the antidote. Just because a child has a phone doesn’t mean they actually need to access every app on it. 

Think about that and the wisdom there. That’s a principle worth building on, and I’m grateful to Common Sense Media and their lead researcher and his colleagues for the careful work that makes that assertion so effectively. It’s the reason that at Troomi we draw a hard line and don’t enable social media apps on the phones that we build for kids. A child’s hours are simply too precious to hand to an algorithm.

So here’s my challenge for all the parents listening. Take a moment and sit down with your kids, not to lecture but to be curious, and ask them what do they truly enjoy on the devices they have? What are the apps that they really enjoy? What are the apps that they really use and get something fulfilling out of, as opposed to just being locked into this soul-crushing doom-scrolling and soul-crushing consumption of YouTube shorts? Find out what… when it does come to the time that they spend on devices, what does make them feel good? What makes them feel like they’ve been constructive or productive or creative? And then help them with the discipline and the guardrails to focus on those things and spend less time or no time on the stuff that is just mind-numbing and doesn’t add to who they are as a person and doesn’t add to their human experience.

I think if you have that conversation with absolute curiosity and really get your kids talking, you’ll discover, just like the kids in this survey, that your kids know what is good for them and what’s not good for them. And I guarantee that if you take the time to figure out… What would your kids like to do with you? Maybe it’s not a grueling backpacking trip in the snow. Maybe it’s something else–playing sports, playing catch, going for walks, whatever it is. I think you’ll always discover that they would rather just have time with you. 

None of us will strike the balance perfectly when it comes to figuring out all the rights and wrongs with kids and phones, but grant yourself and your children the grace to experiment, to slip, and to try again tomorrow. In the end, kids will not remember the hours they spent scrolling. They’re going to remember the hours that they truly lived.

Thanks for joining me today on Protecting Childhood. If this episode resonates with you, please help us reach more parents by sharing it with someone, following the podcast, or leaving a review. Parenting in today’s world isn’t easy, but it is the most important work we can do. Until next time, keep raising kids who thrive beyond the screen.